If You Loved Violet Thistlewaite, These Cozy Fantasy Books Are Next
Disclosure: We are part of the Amazon Affiliate, LTK Creator, Shopmy programs. We will receive a small commission at no cost if you purchase a book. This post may contain links to purchase books & you can read our affiliate disclosure here.
Cozy Fantasy Readers Are Obsessed With These Witchy Comfort Reads
Cozy fantasy, witchy romances, and gentle magic for comfort readers
If you loved Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain Anymore for its low-stakes magic, emotional growth, and cottagecore vibes, you’re probably craving more fantasy that feels comforting instead of chaotic.
These are the books I recommend when readers tell me they want:
- Cozy fantasy without epic wars
- Witchy magic rooted in daily life
- Grumpy/sunshine romance
- Second chances, found family, and emotional healing
- Stories that feel like a warm cup of tea
Here’s where to go next
Listen to Our Latest Podcast
These Cozy Fantasy Books Are Next
A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna
If you loved the emotional heart of Violet Thistlewaite, this is a must-read.
Sera Swan lost most of her magic and now helps run an enchanted inn filled with eccentric guests, found family, and a mischievous talking fox. This book is about second chances, redefining self-worth, and learning that love and community can be just as powerful as magic.Why you’ll love it: Gentle magic, emotional healing, found family, and peak cozy fantasy vibes
The Honey Witch by Sydney J. Shields
A soft, romantic cozy fantasy with folklore-style magic and a beautifully bittersweet premise.
Marigold inherits her role as the Honey Witch—along with a curse that prevents anyone from falling in love with her. When a grumpy skeptic arrives on her island, sparks fly in a way that feels tender, emotional, and quietly powerful.Why you’ll love it: Cottagecore magic, curses, and romance that unfolds gently and thoughtfully.
Reluctant Witch by Melissa Marr
This one leans slightly higher stakes but still appeals to cozy-fantasy readers who want emotional complexity over nonstop action.
A magically bound marriage, buried truths, and a collapsing world push two women to confront trust, betrayal, and love. It’s intimate, romantic, and character-driven—even when the plot intensifies.Why you’ll love it: Emotional fantasy with romance at the center and deeply personal stakes.
The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic & Murder by Kiri Callaghan
If you want cozy fantasy with a mystery twist, this one hits the sweet spot.
A changeling investigator and a reluctant human ally team up to solve supernatural crimes threatening to expose Fey society. It’s witty, clever, and balances magic, friendship, and mystery without losing its cozy feel.Why you’ll love it: Cozy mystery + magic + unlikely partnerships.
The Witching Moon Manor by Stacy Sivinski
This is perfect for readers who love magical sisterhood and returning-home stories.
Following the Quigley sisters as they reunite during a difficult season, this book focuses on healing, reconnection, and rediscovering magic when life doesn’t go as planned.Why you’ll love it: Sisterhood, cozy magic, and the comfort of returning home.
The Magic of Untamed Hearts by Raquel Vasquez Gilliland
A tender magical romance that leans more contemporary but still delivers that cozy-fantasy emotional core.
Sky has always been misunderstood for her magic, and Adam is a disgraced reporter searching for redemption. Their slow-burn connection explores trust, belonging, and the courage it takes to let yourself be seen.Why you’ll love it: Emotional romance, soft magic, and second-chance themes.
the Book Rec Newsletter
Subscribe for weekly book recommendations perfect for a Mood Reading TBR , and update you on new blog posts!
Final Thoughts: Where to Go After Violet Thistlewaite
If Violet Thistlewaite Is Not a Villain Anymore reminded you that fantasy can be soft, healing, and deeply human, these books will keep that feeling going.
They’re perfect for:
- Fall and winter reading
- Readers easing into fantasy
- Cozy-genre lovers who want romance + magic
- Anyone craving comfort reads with emotional depth
If you want more cozy fantasy recs, I’m always sharing them on the What to Read Next Podcast and over on my Substack — especially Kindle Unlimited finds and low-stakes comfort reads.