Must-Read Valentine’s Day Cozy Mysteries for a Sweet & Suspenseful Holiday

Valentine’s Day is the perfect time to curl up with a cozy mystery that combines charm, intrigue, and just the right touch of romance. Whether you love tales set in small towns, stories featuring amateur sleuths, or mysteries with a sprinkle of humor, this list has something for everyone. Best of all, these books are easy to borrow from your library or add to your personal collection. Let’s dive into some delightful Valentine’s Day-themed cozy mysteries that are sure to warm your heart and keep you guessing!

---

What Are Valentine’s Day Cozy Mysteries?

Cozy mysteries are known for their lighthearted tone, quirky characters, and puzzling whodunits. Add a Valentine’s Day twist, and you get mysteries filled with chocolate, love, and sometimes heartbreak. These books often explore themes of community, relationships, and the lighter side of crime-solving—all set against the backdrop of the season of love.

---

Must-Read Valentine’s Day Cozy Mysteries

1. A Catered Valentine’s Day by Isis Crawford

Buy the book
Sisters Bernie and Libby, caterers at A Taste of Heaven, are preparing for a Valentine’s Day fundraiser featuring exotic chocolates and a bachelor auction. But their plans take a dark turn when the body of Ted Gorman, thought to have died weeks earlier, is discovered. As Bernie and Libby uncover scandals, family secrets, and romantic entanglements, they’re drawn deeper into a murder mystery that threatens to upend the event.

2. Murder, Curlers, and Cream by Arlene McFarlane

Buy the book
Beautician Valentine Beaumont is determined to save her struggling salon, but her plans are derailed when a wealthy client is strangled during a facial. Teaming up with a stubborn detective, Valentine dives into solving the case while trying to keep her salon afloat. Humor, romance, and mystery collide in this witty series opener.

3. My Fatal Valentine by Leighann Dobbs

Buy the book
Juniper Holiday’s Valentine’s Day party takes a grim turn when the grand prize winner is found dead. Detective Mallard enlists the help of the mansion’s resident ghosts while Juniper begins her own investigation. A mix of humor, supernatural elements, and mystery makes this a captivating read.

4. Chocolate Covered Murder by Leslie Meier

Buy the book
Reporter Lucy Stone covers a Valentine’s Day promotion in Tinker’s Cove, only to find herself investigating a murder involving Chanticleer’s Chocolates and its sultry manager. As Lucy digs into small-town rivalries, she uncovers secrets that lead her to the killer.

5. Cat Got Your Secrets by Julie Chase

Buy the book
Pet boutique owner Lacy Marie Crocker is juggling Valentine’s Day preparations when she stumbles upon a murder scene. With her father implicated, Lacy must unravel the mystery while managing her store and personal life.

6. Addressed to Kill by Jean Flowers

Buy the book
Postmaster Cassie Miller’s small town is abuzz with Valentine’s Day plans until musician Dennis Somerville is murdered. Cassie suspects a link to local break-ins and sets out to solve the case before another victim is claimed.

7. Killing Cupid by Laura Levine

Buy the book
Freelance writer Jaine Austen’s new job at a matchmaking service takes a sinister turn when her boss is murdered at a Valentine’s mixer. With a long list of suspects, Jaine must navigate twists and turns to unmask the killer.

8. Vistas, Vices, and Valentine by Tonya Kappes

Buy the book
Mae West and the Laundry Club Ladies are drawn into a murder mystery during a Valentine’s dance competition. With secrets and rivalries swirling, Mae must solve the case before it’s too late.

9. A Victim for Valentine’s by Ellie Alexander

Buy the book
Annie Murray’s Valentine’s Day is upended when a local is found dead in her Agatha Christie-themed bookshop. As Annie uncovers clues tied to her past, she must solve the case before the killer strikes again.

10. Death of a Valentine by M.C. Beaton

Buy the book
Police Sergeant Hamish Macbeth’s investigation into a deadly Valentine’s Day gift leads him to uncover motives among the locals of Lochdubh. With humor and Highland charm, this cozy mystery delivers suspense and wit.

11. Valentine Murder by Leslie Meier

Buy the book
Bitsy Howell’s murder in the library basement casts a shadow over Valentine’s Day in Tinker’s Cove. Lucy Stone’s investigation reveals shocking truths about the town’s citizens, leading to a dangerous confrontation.

---

Where to Find These Mysteries

Borrow these cozy mysteries from your local library! If you’re looking to expand your options, check out our Non-Resident Library Cards Guide for access to additional libraries and titles.

---

Explore More Cozy Mysteries

Can’t get enough of cozy mysteries? Visit our Cozy Mystery Hub for more recommendations that span all seasons and themes.

---

Prefer Romance Over Mystery?

If you’re in the mood for a romantic read instead, don’t miss our curated Valentine’s Day Romance List featuring heartwarming love stories perfect for this season.

---

Conclusion

Valentine’s Day is the perfect excuse to indulge in cozy mysteries that combine love, intrigue, and humor. Which of these books will you be picking up? Let us know in the comments, and don’t forget to subscribe to our blog for more bookish recommendations!