Romance Readers Are Falling for These 5 Mystery RomComs

If you love rom-coms but usually avoid mysteries because they feel too dark, too gory, or too stressful, let me reassure you—you’re not alone. This is exactly why I’m so obsessed with Mystery RomComs right now.

These books give you everything romance readers crave—banter, chemistry, slow burns, and emotional payoff—without leaning into serial killers, graphic violence, or high-stress suspense. The mystery exists, yes, but it’s there to push the story forward, not overwhelm it. If you’re romance-first but curious about adding a little plot intrigue, these are the books I always recommend.

---

She Doesn’t Have a Clue by Jenny Elder Moke

A bestselling romance author attends her ex-fiancé’s wedding… only to become the prime suspect when the bride turns up dead. Trapped on a remote island with a cast of publishing insiders, she’ll have to solve the murder herself.

Why You’ll Love It:
This one feels like a rom-com with a murder subplot—sharp banter, undeniable chemistry, and an open-door romance that romance readers will appreciate.

---

Blonde Identity by Ally Carter

A woman wakes up with amnesia, only to discover she might be a spy—and the dangerously charming man chasing her might be part of the problem. As they race across Europe, secrets (and feelings) start to surface.

Why You’ll Love It:
This is romance-forward with mystery and action as the external conflict. Think flirty banter, forced proximity, and high chemistry—perfect for rom-com readers who want more plot momentum.

---

Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder by Bellamy Rose

When her wealthy grandmother dies under suspicious circumstances, NYC heiress Pomona Afton is disinherited and forced to get a job, solve a murder, and figure out who she is without money or status.

Why You’ll Love It:
This is pure rom-com energy—glamorous chaos, fish-out-of-water vibes, and a slow-burn romance layered into a cozy, city-set mystery.

---

The Primrose Murder Society by Stacey Hackny

After her husband’s financial crimes leave her broke, a woman and her daughter are forced into a retirement community—where secrets, scandals, and a suspicious death quickly follow.

Why You’ll Love It:
If you like romance that focuses on family dynamics, personal growth, and emotional stakes alongside a mystery, this one delivers without ever going dark.

---

The Blonde Who Came In from the Cold by Ally Carter

A sequel that leans even harder into romance, this installment ups the emotional stakes while keeping the spy hijinks fast and fun.

Why You’ll Love It:
Perfect for romance readers who want payoff—more relationship development, more tension, and a satisfying continuation of the love story.

---

Why Mystery RomComs Work So Well for Romance Readers

What makes these books special is that the mystery gives the characters something external to solve together. Instead of relying on miscommunication or unnecessary breakups, the plot keeps the story moving while the romance simmers naturally in the background.

If you’ve ever wished rom-coms had a little more plot, or that mysteries felt a little more fun, this genre sits right in that sweet spot.

If you want a deeper breakdown of what makes a book a Mystery RomCom—and how it differs from romantic suspense or cozy mysteries—you can explore my full Mystery RomCom Guide next.

---

Final Thoughts

You don’t have to be a mystery reader to love Mystery RomComs. If you’re here for banter, chemistry, and character-driven stories—and just want something a little different from the standard rom-com formula—these books are the perfect place to start.

Have you tried a Mystery RomCom yet? Or do you have a favorite romance-forward pick I should add to my list? Drop a comment and tell me what to read next.And for more romance-friendly book recs, Kindle Unlimited finds, and library tips, make sure you’re subscribed to my Substack at wtrnblog.substack.com 💕