These Cozy Mysteries Are Leaving Small Towns—and Heading to Big Cities
Disclosure: We are part of the Amazon Affiliate, LTK Creator, Shopmy programs. We will receive a small commission at no cost if you purchase a book. This post may contain links to purchase books & you can read our affiliate disclosure here.
When people hear “cozy mystery,” they often picture small towns, bakeries, and charming villages where everyone knows each other. And while I love that version of cozy, there’s a growing corner of the genre doing something different—Mysteries set in big cities with millennial heroines juggling careers, rent, family, relationships, and murder… inconveniently.
These books keep the humor, banter, and comfort of cozy mysteries but place them in urban settings like New York, San Francisco, and major metro areas. The result? Stories that feel modern, relatable, and perfect if your idea of cozy includes iced coffee, cramped apartments, and chaos.
If you want mysteries that feel current without going dark, start here.
Finlay Donovan Is Killing It by Elle Cosimano
Finlay Donovan is a struggling author, newly divorced, and barely keeping her life together when she’s mistaken for a hitwoman—and somehow ends up tangled in a real murder plot. Set in suburban Virginia with strong city-adjacent energy, this series balances motherhood, money stress, and crime-solving chaos.
Why You’ll Love It:
This is peak millennial survival mode. If you like messy heroines, fast pacing, and humor-driven mysteries, Finlay is the blueprint.
The Eleanor Dash Series by Catherine Mack
Eleanor Dash is a mystery author whose book tours have an alarming habit of ending in murder. From glamorous destinations to very public disasters, Eleanor keeps finding herself at the center of crimes she didn’t sign up to solve.
Why You’ll Love It:
Set largely in cities and travel-heavy locations, this series is perfect if you love meta humor, publishing-world chaos, and big-city energy layered with cozy mystery vibes.
Pomona Afton Can So Solve a Murder by Bellamy Rose
Pomona Afton is a New York City heiress—until her grandmother’s suspicious death leaves her disinherited, broke, and working at a coffee shop while trying to solve a murder.
Why You’ll Love It:
This one screams millennial romcom. NYC setting, influencer fallout, fish-out-of-water energy, and a slow-burn romance make this a standout urban cozy.
Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers by Jesse Q. Sutanto
When a body turns up in her San Francisco tea shop, Vera Wong decides to investigate—whether anyone asks her to or not. What follows is a warm, funny mystery with found family vibes and plenty of meddling.
Why You’ll Love It:
This book captures city life beautifully while still feeling comforting. It’s funny, character-driven, and perfect if you want humor-first mystery energy.
Definitely Maybe Not a Detective by Sarah Fox
Emersyn Gray is absolutely not a detective—she’s a broke twenty-something raising her niece and living in a seniors-only apartment—until a fake detective agency and a very real murder pull her into an investigation she never meant to run. Packed with fake dating energy, accidental sleuthing, and sharp rom-com banter, this urban cozy is perfect if you love messy heroines, modern chaos, and mysteries that feel funny, flirty, and current.
Why You’ll Love It:
This one is peak millennial chaos in the best way. Fake dating energy, accidental sleuthing, financial stress, and rom-com banter collide in an urban setting that feels lived-in and relatable. If you like mysteries where the murder disrupts an already messy life—and the romance is just as compelling as the whodunit—this is a perfect fit for the millennial mystery vibe.
Why Big-City Cozy Mystery Work
What I love most about these books is how real they feel. The characters aren’t retired sleuths or professionals—they’re people with jobs, deadlines, and messy lives. Murder becomes an interruption, not an obsession.
These stories prove that cozy doesn’t have to mean small-town, and that mystery romcoms can thrive in loud, busy, modern spaces without losing their charm.
If you’re curious about how these books fit into the larger Mystery genre, you can explore my full Mystery Guide for a complete breakdown and more recommendations.
Recommended Posts
- Romance Meets Mystery with 14 Mystery RomComs
- 3 Mysteries that feature Austistic Characters
- 3 Locked Room Mysteries set in a Train
- Beachy Cozy Mysteries set in the Hamptons
- Best Queer Cozy Mysteries (Quozies)
Final Thoughts
If you love cozy mysteries but want something that feels a little more now, millennial mysteries set in big cities are the sweet spot. They’re funny, comforting, and full of characters who feel like people you might actually know—or be.
Have a favorite urban cozy or mystery romcom I should add to my list? Leave a comment and let me know what I should read next.And for more book recs, library tips, and Kindle Unlimited finds, don’t forget to subscribe to my Substack at wtrnblog.substack.com 💕
the Book Rec Newsletter
Subscribe for weekly book recommendations perfect for a Mood Reading TBR , and update you on new blog posts!