5 Books Like Tell Me Lies (Toxic Heroes Romance Books)
Disclosure: We are part of the Amazon Affiliate/LTK Creator programs. If you purchase a book, we will receive a small commission at no cost to you. This post may contain links to purchase books, and you can read our affiliate disclosure here.
If you’ve been drawn into the intense world of Tell Me Lies, you know the magnetic pull of a toxic relationship. With his manipulative charm and morally gray actions, Stephen represents the character we love to hate yet can’t seem to look away from. This blend of allure and danger makes the story so addictive. If you’re craving more stories with complex, flawed men who keep you on the edge, you’re in the right place,
In this post, we’ve rounded up a list of dark romance novels featuring toxic men like Stephen, each bringing their own brand of intensity and twisted charm. Prepare to explore the dark, captivating world of flawed heroes who blur the lines between love and obsession.
Tell Me Lies by Carola Lovering
Lucy Albright escapes her Long Island past to start fresh at a small California college, eager to leave behind a betrayal by her mother. She soon meets Stephen DeMarco, a charming but complicated figure who sees in Lucy what no one else does, drawing her into an intense and tumultuous relationship. Stephen, hiding a dark secret, becomes fixated on success and keeping Lucy by his side. Despite her instincts, Lucy can’t break free from their toxic entanglement. Tell Me Lies alternates between their perspectives, exploring the complexities of love, desire, and the difficulty of letting go.
5 Books Like Tell Me Lies (Toxic Heroes Romances)
Descent Sam Mariano
This book is available on Kindle Unlimited. Don’t have KU? Check your Best KU Subscription Offer.
In Descent by Sam Mariano, Calvin Cutler is a ruthless and obsessive man who becomes fixated on the heroine after a single encounter. He pursues her relentlessly, drawing her into his dark and dangerous world. Calvin doesn’t ask for her consent—he takes what he wants, and what he wants is her. This standalone dark romance follows their intense and disturbing relationship, where the villain is unrepentant and the lines between desire and control blur. Not for the faint of heart, it explores themes that may be triggering for some readers.
Vicious by LJ Shen
This book is available on Kindle Unlimited. Don’t have KU? Check your Best KU Subscription Offer.
In Vicious by LJ Shen, Emilia LeBlanc and Vicious Spencer have a tumultuous past filled with unresolved tension. Vicious is ruthless, powerful, and used to getting what he wants, even if it means making Emilia’s life miserable. Ten years ago, he forced her to leave their small town, but now he’s back in her life and determined to claim her once again. Despite their deep hatred, a dark connection pulls them together. This standalone romance is a gritty tale of enemies-to-lovers, where love and hate collide in a story filled with tension and intensity.
Run Posy Run by Cate C. Wells
This book is available on Kindle Unlimited. Don’t have KU? Check your Best KU Subscription Offer.
In Run Posy Run by Cate C. Wells, Posy Santoro thought she found her Prince Charming in Dario Volpe, a powerful man within the mafia. But when he uncovers a secret from her past, everything changes. Now, Posy must flee to escape his deadly obsession. Dario, a ruthless psychopath, isn’t about to let her go without a fight. As she runs for her life, he enjoys the chase, believing Posy is meant for him and no one else. This dark mafia romance is a twisted game of cat and mouse, where love and danger are inseparable.
Try Kindle Unlimited
Unlimited Reading, Unlimited Listening, Any Device
Unlimited, guilt-free reading, all for one low monthly price. Try out new authors, read some of your favorites, and never exceed your book-buying budget!
As an Amazon affiliate, I will get a small commission if you sign up for the service.
God of Malice by Rina Kent
This book is available on Kindle Unlimited. Don’t have KU? Check your Best KU Subscription Offer.
In God of Malice by Rina Kent, Killian Carson is a cunning, charming predator who sets his sights on the heroine, pulling her into his dark, twisted world. Though she tries to escape his dangerous grip, Killian’s relentless pursuit leaves no room for freedom. Behind his polished exterior lies a cold, manipulative monster, and being the only one to see his true nature puts her at great risk. This standalone dark romance delves into obsession, control, and the sinister side of desire, with themes that may not be suitable for all readers.
The Wallflower by J.L. Beck
This book is available on Kindle Unlimited. Don’t have KU? Check your Best KU Subscription Offer.
In The Wallflower by JL Beck, Maybel Jacobs is a shy, socially awkward woman who wants to remain invisible. But her life changes when she crosses paths with a wealthy, dangerous jock whose obsession with her grows the more she resists. Despite her hatred for him, he’s determined to break down her walls and claim her completely. When Maybel joins a dangerous tradition called “The Hunt,” she becomes his target. As the predator, he doesn’t chase—he captures, and he always gets what he wants. This dark romance explores power, control, and obsession with intense and unconventional themes.
Want More Recommendations?
Sign up for our Substack community to get access to an extended list of toxic romance books just like these. Plus, you’ll receive an exclusive podcast episode where we dive deeper into why these books are a must-read for fans of Tell Me Lies. Don’t miss out—click the link to join and discover your next intense, can’t-put-down read!
Conclusion
If Tell Me Lies left you craving more stories featuring complex, toxic men like Stephen, this list has you covered. These dark romances dive deep into the tangled webs of manipulation, obsession, and desire, bringing you unforgettable characters that challenge the boundaries of love and morality. While these reads aren’t for the faint of heart, they offer a thrilling exploration into the darker side of relationships that many of us find so compelling in fiction.