9 Cozy Witch Books to Borrow from the Library This Fall | Magical Reads for Autumn Nights
Disclosure: We are part of the Amazon Affiliate/LTK Creator programs. We will receive a small commission at no cost if you purchase a book. This post may contain links to purchase books & you can read our affiliate disclosure here.
Every fall, I find myself craving cozy stories filled with witches, potions, and a touch of romance—the kind of books that feel like curling up under a blanket with a pumpkin spice latte. There’s just something about witchy reads that makes autumn feel even more magical. Whether it’s small-town spells, grumpy-sunshine romances, or books about rediscovering your magic, these stories are my go-to comfort reads this season.
And the best part? You can find most of these books at your local library—because a little library magic makes everything better.
Here are some of my favorite cozy witch reads to add to your fall TBR.
Never Been Witched by Molly Harper
Premise: Never Been Witched by Molly Harper is a cozy, magical rom-com with a touch of the supernatural. Alice Seastairs, a witch estranged from her coven, spends her days appraising antiques and managing wayward ghosts. When wealthy and charming Collin Bancroft hires her to help restore his family’s haunted hotel, sparks—and spirits—start flying.
Why You’ll Love It: Perfect for fans of paranormal rom-coms, witty banter, and haunted settings with heart.
Buy on Amazon: Never Been Witched by Molly Harper
Hopelessly Teavoted by Audrey Goldberg Ruoff
Premise: In Hopelessly Teavoted, Azrael Hart returns home to Hallowcross to take over his family’s haunted tea shop and reconnects with his childhood best friend, Victoria. But when ghostly warnings and a devil’s curse threaten their lives, their rekindled feelings are as dangerous as the magic surrounding them.
Why You’ll Love It: Ideal for readers who love quirky towns, ghostly parents, forbidden love, and cozy paranormal humor.
Buy on Amazon: Hopelessly Teavoted by Audrey Goldberg Ruoff
Love’s a Witch by Tricia O’Malley
Premise: Sloane MacGregor reluctantly returns to Briarhaven, Scotland, where a family curse and her grumpy former crush, Mayor Knox Douglas, await. Magic and mayhem ensue as the two clash, flirt, and face the secrets of their small town.
Why You’ll Love It: A perfect pick for fans of small-town witchy vibes, enemies-to-lovers sparks, and slow-burn Scottish charm.
Buy on Amazon: Love’s a Witch by Tricia O’Malley
A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna
Premise: When Sera Swan loses her magic after resurrecting her great-aunt, she finds new purpose helping run their whimsical enchanted inn. With the help of a brooding historian, she searches for a spell to restore her powers and rediscovers the true meaning of magic.
Why You’ll Love It: Perfect for readers who adore found family, second chances, and cozy magical settings with heart.
Buy on Amazon: A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna
Watch the Latest Podcast
The Honey Witch by Sydney J. Shields
Premise: Marigold Claude becomes the next Honey Witch of Innisfree, tending to spirits and brewing magic—except she’s cursed so that no one can fall in love with her. When skeptic Lottie Burke arrives on the island, their growing bond tests fate itself.
Why You’ll Love It: A sweet, sapphic romantasy filled with cottagecore magic, curses, and cozy island charm.
Buy on Amazon: The Honey Witch by Sydney J. Shields
Reluctant Witch by Melissa Marr
Premise: Ellie’s just discovered she’s a witch—and is magically bound in marriage to Prospero, the woman who altered her memories. As their realm faces collapse, the two must navigate betrayal and rediscover the truth of their bond.
Why You’ll Love It: Richly emotional and magical, this story blends queer romance, trust, and redemption in a lush fantasy world.
Buy on Amazon: Reluctant Witch by Melissa Marr
The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic & Murder by Kiri Callaghan
Premise: Changeling Avery Hemlock is tasked with investigating supernatural crimes, but her mortal neighbor Saga soon finds herself tangled in Avery’s magical world. Together, they must stop a dangerous threat before it’s too late.
Why You’ll Love It: A cozy fantasy mystery for fans of paranormal investigations, unlikely friendships, and slow-burn chemistry.
Buy on Amazon: The Hearth Witch’s Guide to Magic & Murder by Kiri Callaghan
The Witching Moon Manor by Stacy Sivinski
Premise: The Quigley sisters reunite at the Crescent Moon Tearoom to heal old wounds, rediscover their gifts, and restore balance to their lives. With help from a sharp-tongued necromancer, they confront fate and family magic together.
Why You’ll Love It: A heartwarming tale of sisterhood, second chances, and cozy tea-sipping magic.
Buy on Amazon: The Witching Moon Manor by Stacy Sivinski
The Magic of Untamed Hearts by Raquel Vasquez Gilliland
Premise: Sky Flores, long misunderstood for her magical gifts, agrees to a deal with neighbor Adam Noemi—a reporter who needs a comeback story. As friendship blossoms into love, both must decide what they’re willing to risk for connection.
Why You’ll Love It: Lush prose, second chances, and a touch of magical realism—perfect for readers who love soft, emotional romantasy.
Buy on Amazon: The Magic of Untamed Hearts by Raquel Vasquez Gilliland
Listen to Podcast Interview with Raquel Vasquez Gilliland
Related Posts
- Best Fall Cozy Mystery Read
- How to Borrow Books Digitally from Your Library
- Cozy Cottagecore Romances to Read This Season
Final Thoughts
Whether you prefer your witches with a dash of romance, a sprinkle of humor, or a cozy mystery twist, these magical stories are the perfect companions for fall reading. Light a candle, brew a cup of tea, and let yourself be enchanted.💌 Want more cozy book recs like this? Subscribe to our Substack at wtrnblog.substack.com or leave a comment on the blog with your favorite witchy reads!
Subscribe